Teddi Mellencamp’s affair drama with her married horse trainer has taken a bombshell twist.
The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills alum, 43, announced her split from Edwin Arroyave after 13 years of marriage earlier this month. The former couple share three children.
After it emerged that Mellencamp and Simon Schröeder had a ‘months long affair’, DailyMail.com can reveal that Schröeder’s then wife, Karli Postel Schröeder, filed to nullify their marriage in 2023 because he was legally married to someone else.
Documents filed in Ventura Superior Court in January 2023 by Karli reveal she cited bigamy as the reason to declare their marriage legally invalid.
They wed on November 18 2019.
An Amended Petition for Nullity of Marriage filed on November 6 2023 saw Postel tick the ‘prior existing marriage or domestic partnership’ box as her reason for requesting nullification.
Teddi Mellencamp ‘s affair drama with her married horse trainer before she filed for divorce from Edwin Arroyave has taken a bombshell twist – pictured 2022
After it emerged that Mellencamp and Simon Schröeder had a ‘months long affair’, DailyMail.com can reveal that Schröeder’s wife Karli Postel filed to nullify their marriage in 2023 because he was legally married to someone else (Postel and Simon pictured)
The judgment to nullify their marriage was filed February 29 2024. It is not known who Simon was married to.
Mellencamp and Schröeder were conducting their affair after his and Postel’s marriage was nullified – but as Postel was pregnant with their second child, which arrived around May 2024.
This comes after an insider claimed to DailyMail.com that the the reality star and Schröeder were fooling around behind their spouses’ backs before she filed for divorce.
Making matters worse, the pair were together in Florida while Schröeder’s pregnant partner Karli was giving birth to their second child in California.
‘Karli thought it was suspicious that her husband was in Florida when she was giving birth,’ the source told DailyMail.com.
‘When Simon returned, Karli found text messages on Simon’s phone that exposed the affair.’
‘She confronted Simon and Teddi about it and they confessed. Teddi promised it would not happen again.’
‘Karli didn’t tell Edwin when she found out. She was willing to give Simon another chance and stayed with him. But last month, Karli found proof that the affair was ongoing and that it had become “emotional.”
Documents filed in Ventura Superior Court in January 2023 by Karli Postel Schröeder reveal she cited bigamy as the reason to declare their marriage legally invalid
‘Simon had a history of cheating and Karli was tired of being connected to him. Edwin only learned of the affair late last month when Karli told him.’
The source claims that Teddi decided to file for divorce once she got caught in the affair.
‘She filed for divorce from Edwin so that he did not have the chance to file and get her for adultery. It has been alleged that the marriage ended because Edwin cheated on Teddi, but it is actually the other way around.
Schröeder, who specializes in horse jumping, had been training Mellencamp’s horse Totally, nicknamed ‘Toad.’
On May 29, his wife congratulated her husband and Mellencamp on Toad’s success at a horse show.
‘So beyond proud of Simon’s hard work with Teddi Mellencamp’s Totally!’ Postel wrote on Instagram.
‘Beautiful consistent rounds at the Devon Horseshow in the High Performance… a huge feat from where Simon & Toad’s journey began,’ she continued, before adding: ‘Can’t wait to watch Teddi take on the weekend.’
Mellencamp and Arroyave are reportedly feuding over spousal support amid their contentious divorce battle
Mellencamp ‘liked’ the post and still follows Postel on Instagram. Postel does not follow her back.
Mellencamp praised Schröeder on May 31, around the time his wife gave birth, as he rode Toad at the Devon Horse Show.
‘I am Totally obsessed with you Toady baby boy,’ she wrote alongside a video of her horse in the competition. ‘Everything I have asked of you, you have done. Thank you for making my first time in the @devon1896 ring in 25 years a dream.
‘I feel so blessed you are mine. Thank you to @simonschroeder85 for the excellent rides on him earlier this week and to @schroedersporthorses @windsong2121 for all you have done to make this show happen.’
Just 12 weeks ago she praised Schröeder and Schroeder Sporthorses – a ‘Hunter, Jumper and Equitation training, sales and investments show barn’ – again and thanked him for the ‘stunning rides.’
‘Thank you @Schroedersporthorses… for always being team Toad,’ she wrote. ‘I’m forever grateful to you for selling me the most fun horse I have ever ridden.’
DailyMail.com contacted a rep for Mellencamp but they had no comment.
Postel also said no comment, while Schröeder refused to comment when contacted.
Mellencamp and Arroyave are reportedly feuding over spousal support amid their contentious divorce battle.
On Friday, Arroyave filed his response to Mellencamp’s divorce petition and is reportedly pushing back on her custody and spousal support requests.
Mellencamp had requested primary custody of their three kids with ‘reasonable and frequent visitation’ for Arroyave in her divorce filing
Mellencamp had requested primary custody of their three children — Slate, 12, Cruz, 10, and Dove, 4 — with ‘reasonable and frequent visitation’ for Arroyave in her divorce filing, which she filed last week and announced a day later on November 2.
According to legal documents, Arroyave is contesting and asking for joint physical and legal custody of their minor children.
Her soon-to-be ex-husband also revealed in the latest court documents that they have a prenuptial agreement he wants the court to enforce.
This comes after it was revealed that the now-estranged pair were in couples therapy ‘for years’ before their separation
He opposed her request for him to provide her with spousal support and to terminate the court’s ability to award Arroyave spousal support.
In his petition, Arroyave requested that Mellencamp should be the one to pay him spousal support and asked that the court terminate their ability to award her with any support.
Citing their prenup, he stated in his response: ‘The parties’ Premarital Agreement sets forth the terms regarding the amount and duration of spousal support to be paid.’
Arroyave also checked both their names to pay their attorney’s fees after Mellencamp had requested that Arroyave be solely responsible for all of the legal costs.
Her soon-to-be ex-husband also revealed in the latest court documents, which were obtained by Us Weekly , that they have a prenuptial agreement he wants the court to enforce
Arroyave also claimed the prenup determined that ‘all assets, income from all sources, and obligations of each party are his/her separate property, except as specifically set forth Therein.’
And contrary to the reality star’s filing, Arroyave listed their official date of separation as November 1 while Mellencamp claimed they split on October 20.
Mellencamp is the daughter of famed singer-songwriter John Mellencamp.
She shot to fame after joining The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills in 2017, and remained on the show for three seasons as a full time cast member before getting the axe.
Since then, she has starred on Celebrity Big Brother and Name That Tune, and hosts the successful Real Housewives podcast Two Ts in a Pod with Tamra Judge.
